This blog is inspired by myriad important family law issues that current South Carolina case law and statute don’t adequately answer. None of these questions is merely academic, as each has come up at least once in my eighteen years of family law practice. I have firm opinions on the correct answer to some of these questions (the hypertext links are to writings in which I have discussed the issue, even if it’s buried in a footnote), and can make educated guesses about the ultimate answer to many, but there’s currently no definitive answer to any.
All of these questions are capable of definitive answer by case law or statute. That none of them are is due to our legislature’s and appellate court’s continued–and inexplicable–preference for vesting great discretion in family court judges. Huge swaths of family law–equitable distribution; alimony; child custody–vest the family court judge with tremendous discretion. Child support is the one area of family law in which federal law requires clear guidelines and child support disputes tend to be less expensive to resolve than other disputes because attorneys can more reasonably predict outcomes. However, when the courts have great discretion in fashioning decisions, it becomes much harder to predict outcomes, and gives parties more incentive to litigate.
These unresolved issues in family law range from the highly technical (treatment of subchapter S income that doesn’t increase a parent’s spendable income) to grandly philosophical (what is a father?). Some of these questions have clear(er) answers in other states. Yet, even for issues that call for clear rule setting (when should a party in default be allowed to seek relief?; when should the court employ shared custody child support guidelines) our appellate courts have merely vested our family courts with discretion without providing any guidance on what factors should shape that discretion. With South Carolina being a state of below average median income, jurisprudence should encourage clear rules in order to reduce legal fees. Too often our appellate courts favor the vesting of great discretion in family court judges over providing clear guidance to the family court bench and bar. Unless the goal is to maximize judicial power, this prudential preference is inexplicable.
Divorce
2. What is the burden of proof for adultery?
3. How much detail does the other spouse need to know for adultery to be condoned?
5. How much subsequent “fault” does there need to be to negate condonation?
6. Is “third base” adultery?
7. Is “second base” adultery?
8. How long can a spouse remain in the home after the last physical abuse incident without that physical abuse being considered condoned?
9. Are postnuptial reconciliation agreements valid?
10. Can the family court order a spouse out of the house on an ex-parte basis?
11. Is the law prohibiting adultery unconstitutional?
Alimony
12. If the burden of proof for an adultery divorce is “clear and convincing evidence” is that also the burden of proof to invoke adultery’s bar to alimony?
13. If, after the court issues a final order of separate maintenance or divorce, the supported spouse commits adultery, and that order is later vacated or reversed, does that adultery bar alimony?
14. If the parties enter a separation agreement that a supported spouse repudiates prior to court approval, would that supported spouse’s post-agreement adultery bar him or her from receiving alimony?
15. If the supporting spouse is not “at fault” for the breakup of the marriage and is willing to take the other spouse back, can the family court award alimony?
16. Is refusal to engage in sexual intimacies a fault factor in determining alimony?
17. Is having close personal friendship that one’s spouse disapproves of, especially if that friendship is with a member of the opposite sex, a fault factor in determining alimony?
18. Is there a retirement age for alimony obligors?
19. Do the statutory factors for setting alimony apply to actions to modify alimony?
20. How does length of a marriage affect the amount of monthly alimony?
21. Does length of marriage affect the amount of alimony, whether the alimony should be rehabilitative or permanent, or both?
22. If a spouse wilfully undertakes an action that permanently impairs his or her earning capacity, can the previous earning capacity be used to set alimony?
Paternity
Child custody/visitation
27. In custody cases, does the family court have authority to make legal custody type decisions for a child (e.g., which school the child will attend; whether a child can get elective surgery) or does the court merely have authority to decide who gets to decide?
28. In custody cases, can the family court issue restraints against third parties (grandparents; step parents) that they do not consent to?
29. Does the non custodial parent have the right to delegate his or her visitation to a third party?
30. Is there a difference between child custody and guardianship of a child?
31. When should sibling visitation be awarded?
32. How many sexual partners in how short a time period does it take to make a parent’s sexual behavior “promiscuous,” and therefore relevant without a showing that the behavior affected the child?
34. Can grandparent visitation still be awarded merely because the grandparent’s child is deceased?
35. If a seventeen year old moves in with the non-custodial parent does the family court have any authority to make the child move back?
36. Can one arbitrate child custody issues?
37. Does the restraint against exposing children overnight to unmarried romantic companions deny due process or equal protection to homosexuals (since they cannot marry)?
39. Can and should the court ever appoint independent counsel for an older child involved in a custody dispute?
40. Is having custody of one’s own child per se emancipation?
42. Can the court consider a parent’s religious observance, independent of ancillary issues such as that observance’s impact upon a child, as a factor in awarding custody?
43. How long does a child have to be in a third party’s physical possession before the Moore v. Moore, 300 S.C. 75, 386 S.E.2d 456, 458 (1989) factors become applicable?
44. What aspects of a parent’s homosexuality, if any, are relevant in custody determinations?
45. In custody battles between parties who are not the child’s parents, is preference given to someone who is a blood relative of a child?
Child support
48. Other than a history of late payment, what factors should the court consider in deciding whether to make a party pay support through the court (and incur a 5% administrative fee)?
49. If a parent wilfully undertakes an action that permanently impairs his or her earning capacity, can the previous earning capacity be used to set child support?
50. How should contribution towards private school tuition impact application of the child support guidelines?
51. How should child support be set when some of the parties’ children are in a shared custody situation and some are in a sole custody situation?
53. When two mothers are seeking child support from the same father, should the first child support calculation be based on the oldest child or the first to file?
54. Should a parent’s undergraduate school loan payments impact income for setting child support?
55. Should a parent’s graduate or professional school loan payments impact income for setting child support?
56. Is subchapter S Corporation income used to pay taxes still income for child support purposes if the parent has a controlling interest in the S Corporation?
57. Is subchapter S Corporation income used to pay taxes still income for child support purposes if the parent does not have a controlling interest in the S Corporation?
58. Can the court order child support for a disabled adult child if that child had the disability before age eighteen but the condition only became disabling after age eighteen?
59. Is court-ordered support for a disabled adult child still constitutional after Webb v. Sowell, 387 S.C. 328, 692 S.E.2d 543 (2010)?
60. If an eighteen year old high school student moves in with the non-custodial parent, does that give rise to child support modification?
62. Does evidentiary or proof laches remain a defense to child support or alimony obligations?
Equitable distribution
63. How much can the court deviate from a 50/50 division of marital assets in a short term marriage?
64. How can the family court take jurisdiction over the parties’ property without first determinating it is marital?
65. Is it just the owner’s intent or is it the parties’ intent that determines whether property is transmuted?
67. How should the court value and equitably divide pets?
Family court procedure
68. When filing to modify support or custody, is venue proper in the county of the final order, the county of the defendant’s residence, or both?
69. Unless the previous final order explicitly states it, how does one determine where a change of circumstances is “anticipated” or “unanticipated”?
70. Is an adverse finding from invoking a 5th amendment privilege against self incrimination mandatory or discretionary? If discretionary, what factors should the court consider in exercising this discretion?
71. Is attorney-client privilege waived on attorney fee issues if a party is seeking attorney’s fees?
72. Is a mediator allowed (required) to testify if a party claims he or she was coerced into executing an agreement during the mediation?
73. Is a mediator allowed to inform the court that a party mediated in “bad faith”?
74. In responding to a request for production, who is responsible for retrieval and copying costs for records that are in a party’s control but not in that party’s possession?
75. What is the effect of default in family court?
76. Can the court reconsider temporary orders merely because a party disagrees with the ruling?
77. If child support and alimony obligations are judgments, why aren’t temporary orders on these issues immediately appealable?
78. Since temporary custody orders will become moot upon the issuance of a final order, why aren’t they immediately appealable?
79. Can one issue subpoenas duces tecum without an order of discovery? Evidently the answer is no: In the Matter of Margaret D. Fabri
80. Does one have a “due process” right to demand testimony at temporary hearings?
81. Is a statement that is signed and notarized but not “sworn” before a notary a valid affidavit?
82. Are all family court motions “temporary motions” as defined by Rule 21, SCRFC?
83. Can the family court issue a temporary order providing relief that is retroactive to the date of filing of the motion?
84. Does one have the right to ask leading questions of one’s client on “cross-examination” if the opposing party called the client as his or her own witness?
85. Is service of motions, affidavits or orders via facsimile or email valid service?
86. Does “ex parte communication” merely refer to communication with a judge that takes place without the other party’s knowledge or presence or does it refer to all communications that take place outside of court or formal motion proceedings?
87. When a family court judge questions a witness, can one raise evidentiary objections?
88. Where a motion for an order for protection from domestic abuse is brought in an ongoing action, does the hearing proceed via testimony or affidavit?
Abuse and neglect cases
90. Does the child hearsay exception of S.C. Code §19-1-180 violate the 6th Amendment?
Attorney’s fees and costs
91. When child custody jurisdiction is based solely upon the child’s residence, and not upon the defendant’s residence, does the family court have jurisdiction to make the defendant pay the plaintiff’s attorneys fees?
92. When child custody jurisdiction is based solely upon the child’s residence, and not upon the defendant’s residence, does the family court have jurisdiction to require the defendant to pay any costs (such as guardian fees)?
93. Does Rule 54(d), SCRCP give a party a right to seek bifurcation of attorney’s fees, with that issue to be resolved after the final judgment?
94. Should the fact that the lower income party retained a higher charging attorney be a factor in awarding attorney’s fees?
Contempt
95. Does the “clear and convincing” burden of proof for contempt just go to proving contempt or does it also go proving damages?
97. Are the parties’ abilities to pay fees a factor in awarding fees from a contempt action?
98. What is the proper procedure to enforce compliance with a court order when the other party’s non-compliance isn’t willful?
99. When an opposing party cannot comply with a provision of a final order that is non-modifiable, what remedies are available (that is, can the family court then modify the provision at the other’s party’s request)?
Greg
You ask a lot of questions for a guy from Chicago.
s/Rosanne Rosanadana
Greg, this is stunningly thorough work. I would seriously urge that you share this work with the South Carolina Conference of Family Court Judges (a great many of these “points” and “issues” have been frequently discussed by and among the family court judges at their various conferences).
Very impressive, Greg! How much is a law professor’s salary these days? Compelling and interesting questions!
Greg:
I just sent you the answer to #9. I just copied all 100 to a Word Perfect file and I am going to try to answer at least one per day for the next three months. I will share my answers with you when I finish. I have lots of questions too but mine are much more petty and nit-picking.
Thomas,
What you sent me was an unpublished opinion. I do not believe unpublished opinions can be relied upon to answer any of these questions.
Fantastic work, Greg.
WOW! You know I am not an attorney but for a layman is seems like quite a comprehensive list.
Would love to know the answer to #9
My boyfriend has been paying child support since 2008. In December 2013 he collapsed on the job. He had to have surgery for a collapsed disk and bone spurs that had grown in the spinal canal and had caused nerve damage. The doctor refused to release him to go back to work due to, limb weakness, leg unexpectedly gives out, advanced degenerative disc disease and the constant pain caused by arthritis and the permanent nerve damage. He just recently had a spinal nerve stimulator implanted to help deal with the pain. He was getting long term disability. While waiting on the approval for the implant his long term disability was stopped. Their reason was “lack of activity” although nothing could be done during that waiting period. He has tapped out all money resources paying medical and child support while I pay living expenses. My question is this. How does one pay child support while truly unable to work, with no income or other money options until DSSI is approved? The judge said he’s not proven disabled until a doctor puts in writing that he is (even after seeing medical records) and the doctors want put it in writing until his procedures are complete and he’s been evaluated. Hes stuck in the middle of two systems and drowning due to them and now being threatened with jail. I can’t afford to pay the child support for him. Are there no options for this in between stage to save him?
My fiance is legally divorced from his wife, however, they have a daughter thst lives with her is south carolina and he lives in Ohio. Since the dissolution of marriage was done out of state no custody order was made. She refuses to let him see talk to or have anything to do with their daughter. Without a court order can he do anything?